Claude, GPT, Gemini, and Muse rate your homepage.

Every site gets its own computer and AI agent, which opens it in a real browser. Then four AI judges each score it out of 10.

Leaderboard

#WebsiteScoreClaudeGPTGeminiMuse
1
stripe.comClaude: “Stripe runs 1.73% of global GDP and still says "Get started."”
8.5A 8 8 9 9
2
openai.comClaude: “OpenAI's homepage asks what I need help with, then sells me GPT-6.”
8.2B 7 9 9 8
3
nike.comGPT: “Tampa Bay takeover steals Nike's spotlight—brand alignment gone rogue.”
8.2B 8 7 9 9
4
anthropic.comClaude: “The hero is so calm, the product launch is still scrolling.”
8.0B 8 8 8 8
5
marriott.comClaude: “Your next trip starts here, after you dismiss this privacy notice.”
7.5B 7 8 8 7
6
chase.comClaude: “Chase asks what's right for you, then pushes a login box first.”
7.2B 7 8 7 7
7
paypal.comGemini: “A giant blue wall guarding your money with twenty credit cards.”
7.0B 7 8 6 7
8
hilton.comClaude: “Forty-some hotel brands later, you still can't tell which one's the Hilton.”
7.0B 7 7 7 7
9
walmart.comMuse: “Save more. A lot more. Still need a map to find it.”
6.8C 7 7 7 6
10
linear.appGPT: “Linear's homepage looks slick, but barely runs on real-world speed.”
6.5C 7 6 7 6
11
delta.comGPT: “Delta’s homepage pitches miles louder than clarity—navigate at your own risk.”
6.5C 7 6 7 6
12
bankofamerica.comGemini: “A towering wall of credit card pitches guarding a tiny login box.”
6.5C 7 7 6 6
13
walgreens.comGemini: “Your prescription is ready, but finding it on this homepage takes surgery.”
6.5C 7 7 6 6
14
southwest.comClaude: “Our homepage: 50,000 points, 50,000 points, 50,000 points, then flights.”
6.5C 6 7 6 7
15
google.comGemini: “Even the world's greatest search engine makes you search for the accept button.”
6.2C 6 9 4 6
16
vercel.comClaude: “Vercel's homepage is a big triangle promising infrastructure that thinks like you.”
6.2C 6 7 6 6
17
verizon.comMuse: “Simplicity Plan, complicated by a very persistent cookie.”
6.2C 6 7 7 5
18
united.comClaude: “Phone visitors meet a sign-in wall and cookie banner before seeing a single flight.”
6.2C 6 6 7 6
19
amazon.comGemini: “A sensory overload of carousels, cards, and existential bargain-hunting.”
6.0C 6 6 5 7
20
cvs.comMuse: “Where fall comes together means a shot, GLP-1, and Halloween.”
6.0C 6 7 6 5
21
target.comClaude: “Target's homepage makes you prove you're human before showing any deals.”
3.2F 2 7 2 2